Why Taller Grass Can Be Bad News For Grasshoppers

Mar 10, 2020
Originally published on March 10, 2020 5:20 pm

In northeastern Kansas, there's an open-air ecological laboratory called Konza Prairie. Scientists like Ellen Welti go there to study plants, insects, and big animals. "In the spring it has a lot of beautiful flowers, it has bison; everybody should go visit and check it out for themselves," says Welti, who is currently a post-doctoral researcher at the University of Oklahoma.

In this landscape, grasshoppers play a crucial role. They eat the grass; birds eat them.

Welti and her colleagues noticed that data collected over the past two decades showed the number of grasshoppers declining. Yet it wasn't for lack of food. The amount of grass on this prairie actually has been increasing, which Welti found "kind of interesting."

The researchers wondered if perhaps the crucial factor wasn't the amount of grass available to eat, but its nutritional content. "Grasshoppers, even compared to other insects, are more sensitive to changes in plant quality," Welti says.

Fortunately, they could test this hypothesis. Scientists have collected samples of grass that grew at Konza Prairie each year for the past 20 years or so. Those samples were stored in a shed. When the scientists tested them, they found that, indeed, in more recent years the grass contained lower levels of certain key nutrients, including nitrogen (which is a measure of protein levels), phosphorus, and potassium.

Welti and her colleagues think that they know the reason for all this, and it's related to the changing climate. There's more carbon dioxide in the air now, which plants need in order to grow. Also, the climate is warmer. Both things make grass grow faster.

The scientists think that this, in turn, is what led to lower amounts of those crucial nutrients. Scientists have observed this "nutrient dilution" when they've grown plants in the lab with artificially high levels of carbon dioxide.

The declines in nutrient levels in the grass samples at Konza Prairie "are pretty striking," Welti says. "So it seems like a pretty logical explanation for grasshopper declines."

Her team's study was published this week in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

"It's an interesting paper, for sure," says Spencer Behmer, an entomologist at Texas A&M University who also studies grasshoppers. The new study, he says, shows the value of long-term ecological observations at sites like Konza Prairie, where scientists collected samples of grass over many years without ever knowing what those samples might someday reveal.

These observations could have implications for human nutrition, too, Behmer says. Crops that humans eat also are affected by carbon dioxide levels and climate change — although people have more food options than grasshoppers do.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Scientists think that grass on the prairie is growing taller because there's now more carbon dioxide in the air. You might think that would be good for wildlife. But as NPR's Dan Charles reports, it could actually be hurting them.

DAN CHARLES, BYLINE: In northeastern Kansas, there's an open-air ecological laboratory called Konza Prairie. Scientists like Ellen Welti study the wildlife there - the plants, the insects, the big animals.

ELLEN WELTI: In the spring, it has a lot of beautiful flowers. It has bison.

CHARLES: In this landscape, grasshoppers play a really important role. They eat the grass. Birds eat them. But Welti and her colleagues noticed the number of grasshoppers has been declining over the past 20 years. It wasn't for lack of food. The amount of grass growing there has actually been increasing.

WELTI: And so we thought that was kind of interesting that as there is more plants, the grasshoppers are actually declining.

CHARLES: And then they had a thought. Maybe it's not the amount of grass, but its nutritional content.

WELTI: Grasshoppers, even compared to other insects, are more sensitive to changes in plant quality.

CHARLES: Fortunately, scientists had collected samples of grass that grew at Konza Prairie every year for the past 20 years or so.

WELTI: It was stored in a shed near Konza Prairie, and then we went back and did the chemistry on it.

CHARLES: And they found that, indeed, in more recent years, the grass contained lower levels of certain key nutrients - protein, phosphorus, potassium. Welti thinks the reason is there's more carbon dioxide in the air now, which plants need to grow. Also, the climate is warmer. And both things make plants grow faster. And growing faster, she thinks, is what led to lower amounts of those crucial nutrients. Scientists have observed this so-called nutrient dilution when they've grown plants in the lab with high levels of CO2.

WELTI: These declines in nutrients over time are really pretty striking, so it seems like a pretty logical explanation for our grasshopper declines.

CHARLES: Welti's study appeared this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Other grasshopper experts say it makes sense to them, like Spencer Behmer at Texas A&M University.

SPENCER BEHMER: It's a interesting paper for sure.

CHARLES: Behmer says it shows how valuable it is to observe nature carefully over many years, collecting samples of grass without knowing what they might someday show.

BEHMER: They took advantage of samples that existed and analysis that existed from a long-term ecological study site.

CHARLES: There could be implications for people, Behmer says. Crops that humans eat also will be affected by carbon dioxide levels and climate change, although humans have more food options than grasshoppers do.

Dan Charles, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.